BBB National Programs Archive
CARU Recommends Fisher-Price Modify Future Advertising To Better Depict Adult Supervision
New York, NY – April 1, 2009 – The Children’s Advertising Review Unit of the Council of Better Business Bureaus, Inc., has recommended that Fisher-Price modify advertising to assure that broadcast advertising for “Power Wheels Barbie Jammin’ Jeep Wrangler” adequately depicts adult supervision.
Advertising for the product came to the attention of CARU through its routine monitoring practices. The commercial in question showed two girls, approximately four years of age, driving a Barbie Jammin’ Jeep Wrangler around an animated setting. The girls appeared in live-action as they drove through the fantasy environment which included a beach, a shopping area and a forest. The advertising aired during children’s programming.
An adult female, also in live-action, appeared briefly in the commercial and waved to the children as she walked in the opposite direction carrying packages in the shopping area. At the end of the commercial, one girl turned and waved over her shoulder. The commercial included an audio and written disclosure stating “Parental supervision is required.”
The advertiser asserted that the commercial ad portrayed both an adult figure clearly supervising the actions of the children as they drove the vehicle, and that the children understood they were being watched as evidenced by the girls’ wave back to the adult – “a continuous visual demonstration of adult supervision, reinforced by audio and written disclosures about adult supervision.”
The advertiser noted that both product packaging and the owner’s manual include a “WARNING” stating that “direct adult supervision is required” and to “keep children within safe riding areas.” Fisher-Price stated that these messages also appear on a decal affixed to the product. Further, the advertiser said, product packaging and the instruction manual reinforce the message that adult supervision is required.
CARU noted in its decision that the adequate depiction of parental supervision in any case is one of degree. When the use of a product could be potentially unsafe to children, the quantity and quality of the depiction of adult supervision both come into play.
Following its review of the advertising at issue, CARU determined that the interaction between the adult and the children did not rise to the level of adequate parental supervision. CARU recommended that Fisher-Price depict active and direct parental supervision in advertisement for all products that present a risk of injury or damage.
The company said in its advertiser’s statement that it is “disappointed that CARU disagrees that an adequate level of adult supervision was depicted … .”
“As always,” the company said, it will “take CARU’s guidelines and recommendations into account in future advertising.”