For Developers: Get to Know the CARU Advertising Guidelines

Sep 14, 2021 by Cameryn Gonnella, Compliance Manager, Children’s Advertising Review Unit

The mobile app ecosystem looks drastically different today than it did a few years ago, and no one knows that better than app developers. Mobile advertising is more dynamic and sophisticated than ever before. As the experts on advertising directed to children both on and offline, the Children’s Advertising Review Unit (CARU) has modernized its Advertising Guidelines to reflect the new ways that children engage with apps and mobile advertising. 

The CARU Advertising Guidelines are widely recognized industry standards that help ensure advertising directed to children is fair and appropriate for its intended audience across any form of child-directed media. Here are some key revisions to the Guidelines to which mobile developers should pay heed.

 

Blurring of Advertising and Content

In mobile formats, it can be easy for the line between app content and in-app ads to get blurry. In-app ads can look like organic posts from users, such as promoted posts on Twitter or Instagram. They can also take the form of additional features within the app itself.  

To make sure child users can tell when content is advertising, CARU’s Guidelines state that any ads integrated into the content of a game or activity should be easily identifiable as ads. 

For example, in a child’s gaming app that displays a glittering treasure chest icon, which when clicked shows an ad prior to issuing in-game rewards, that ad must be properly disclosed as such. Absent a disclosure that makes it clear clicking on the treasure chest will display an ad – rather than just another feature of the game itself – the treasure chest would likely not comply with CARU’s new Blurring Guideline. 

 

From concept to final cut, CARU’s pre-screening services help businesses and agencies spot and correct problems before ads go live. Learn more.

     

    Unfair, Deceptive, or Manipulative Tactics

    Another new addition in the revised CARU Guidelines prohibits advertisements, apps, or other games from using unfair, deceptive, or manipulative tactics to encourage children to view more ads or to make in-app purchases. The treasure chest feature, described above, could likely manipulate a child to engage with an ad. App developers and advertisers should take special care not to cause children to unknowingly or inadvertently engage with an ad.

    Other manipulative tactics could include making the ad so small or indistinguishable from another feature in the app that the child accidentally clicks on it. The position, color, or size of the ad should not be disguised in a manner that will manipulate children. To comply with CARU’s Guidelines, developers should take care to ensure that any ads served within apps and games are easily recognizable as ads. 

     

    Clear Access to Dismiss an Ad

    The new Guidelines also state that methods to dismiss or exit an ad should be clear and conspicuous to children. The Guidelines do not mean that all in-app or in-game ads must have an exit method, but they do require that any available exit method must be noticeable and understandable to children, e.g., a large “X” that contrasts with the background color of the ad.

     

    In-App or In-Game Purchases

    Finally, the new Guidelines governing in-app or in-game purchases require advertisers, apps, or games that offer purchases to make it clear to children that purchases involve real money. This Guideline was put in place partly due to reports of children unwittingly spending hundreds of dollars in apps, likely because children did not understand they were using their parent’s or guardian’s real, hard-earned money. 

     

    Have Questions?

    You can read the new CARU Advertising Guidelines in full here . Still have questions? CARU is hosting its second annual Kidvertising event on Wednesday, October 13. This half-day virtual workshop will provide you or the appropriate member of your team with hands-on knowledge about how to comply with the new Guidelines. Find out more and register here .

    Suggested Articles

    Blog

    When Organizations Market To Children, They Should Do So Responsibly

    Today's generation of digital natives might be more comfortable navigating gaming and content platforms, but they face the same cognitive limitations — and vulnerabilities — that children always have. The gap between a child’s needs online and the safeguards in place to protect them in digital spaces has grown to the point where big players like Google and Facebook are making more of an effort to address these gaps.
    Read more
    Blog

    What Is Arbitration and What Should You Expect from It?

    Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution and is an alternative to litigation (going to court). In some cases, a process called mediation will precede arbitration. In fact, more than 60% of claims that come through AUTO LINE are resolved in mediation. But, if a dispute cannot be resolved in mediation, the claim will proceed to arbitration.
    Read more
    Blog

    The Potential Cost of Misleading Income Claims

    The FTC recently put direct sellers, and other companies offering money-making opportunities, on notice: false promises about earnings potential and other aspects of a company’s business opportunity could subject the company to civil penalties. DSSRC published the Guidance on Earnings Claim for the Direct Selling Industry to reinforce fundamental tenets regarding the dissemination of earnings claims by direct selling companies and their independent salesforce members.
    Read more
    Blog

    In-App and In-Game Ads: Tips to Staying Compliant in 2022

    Today, children have increased access to technology as well as increased screen time, using apps and playing games, reading books, doing their homework, creatively expressing themselves, and socializing on their devices. As a result, business models have adapted, with apps reliant on ads and in-app purchases for revenue, rather than up-front purchase fees. These new business models require special design considerations outlined in CARU's revised Advertising Guidelines.
    Read more