National Advertising Division Finds Certain Claims for Old Trapper Beef Jerky are Puffery, Recommends Superiority Claims be Modified or Discontinued
New York, NY – January 8, 2024 – In a challenge brought by competitor Link Snacks, Inc., BBB National Programs’ National Advertising Division determined that in context “The Best” and “Clearly the Best” claims made by Old Trapper Smoked Products, Inc. for its Old Trapper Smoked Beef Jerky are puffery and not objective assertions of fact that Old Trapper jerky is “the best.”
However, the National Advertising Division (NAD) recommended that Old Trapper discontinue the challenged ingredient claims to avoid conveying the message that they are using superior ingredients.
“The Best” and “Clearly the Best” Claims
NAD determined that the following claims were puffery:
- Clearly the Best Beef Jerky.
- The Best Ingredients Create the Best Beef Jerky.
- Old Trapper is Clearly the Best Beef Jerky. Clearly More. Clearly Nothing to Hide. Clearly Fresh. Clearly the Best.
NAD noted that:
- Old Trapper’s “Clearly the Best Beef Jerky” slogan, when used on its product packaging and website, conveys a message of corporate pride, and the use of “best” is not comparative as no specific competitor or ingredient is identified. In these contexts, the challenged claims are unquantifiable and therefore, puffery.
- The claim “The Best Ingredients Create the Best Beef Jerky” which appears prominently on the Old Trapper website landing page, did not convey a specific comparative superiority message.
- Old Trapper’s 15-second YouTube video that depicted a single bag of Old Trapper jerky while “Old Trapper is Clearly the Best Beef Jerky. Clearly More. Clearly Nothing to Hide. Clearly Fresh. Clearly the Best”, did not convey a comparative superiority message because the video only featured Old Trapper, did not tout attributes other than a single reference to “clearly fresh,” and did not refer to or depict any competitors or competitors’ products.
Ingredient Claims
Regarding the claim made on Old Trapper’s social media account, “We use only the highest quality ingredients in every Old Trapper flavor. That’s just one of the reasons why Old Trapper is #ClearlyTheBest,” NAD determined that the language “We use only the highest quality ingredients” is an objective claim that requires support.
In the absence of any support that Old Trapper uses the highest quality ingredients, NAD recommended that Old Trapper discontinue or modify these claims to avoid conveying the message that they are using superior ingredients.
In its advertiser statement, Old Trapper stated that it “agrees to comply with NAD’s recommendations in this matter” and “appreciates NAD’s careful consideration of the issues presented.”
All BBB National Programs case decision summaries can be found in the case decision library. For the full text of NAD, NARB, and CARU decisions, subscribe to the online archive. Per NAD/NARB procedures, this release shall not be used for advertising or promotional purposes.
Subscribe to the Ad Law Insights or Privacy Initiatives newsletters for an exclusive monthly analysis and insider perspectives on the latest trends and case decisions in advertising law and data privacy.
Latest Decisions
In National Advertising Division Challenge Admire Aesthetics Voluntarily Discontinues Claims for Compounded Tirzepatide
New York, NY – January 23, 2025 – In a BBB National Programs’ National Advertising Division challenge brought by Eli Lilly, Admire Aesthetics voluntarily discontinued certain advertising claims for its compounded tirzepatide product.
National Advertising Division Finds Certain Claims for Brainiac Applesauce and Gummy Vitamins Supported; Recommends Others be Discontinued or Modified
New York, NY – January 22, 2025 – The National Advertising Division determined that Ingenuity Brands provided a reasonable basis for certain claims for its Brainiac Brain Squeezers Applesauce products and BrainPack Daily Adult Gummy Vitamins, but recommended other claims be discontinued or...
National Advertising Division Recommends Procter & Gamble Modify or Discontinue Certain #1 Claims for Tide Free & Gentle
New York, NY – January 17, 2025 – The National Advertising Division recommended that P&G modify the claim “From Tide, the #1 brand used by dermatologists” when used in connection with imagery for Tide Free & Gentle and discontinue the related claim “From Tide, the #1 Trusted Detergent Brand for Sensitive...
National Advertising Division Recommends T-Mobile Discontinue “Families Can Save 20% Every Month Versus AT&T and Verizon” Claim
New York, NY – January 16, 2025 – In a Fast-Track SWIFT challenge brought by competitor AT&T, BBB National Programs’ National Advertising Division recommended T-Mobile discontinue its claim for 20% savings on monthly wireless services.