Thane International, Inc. Participates In ERSP Self-Regulatory Forum

New York, NY – June 30, 2005 – The Electronic Retailing Self-Regulation Program (ERSP), the electronic direct-response industry’s self-regulatory forum supervised by the National Advertising Review Council (NARC), announced that Thane International, Inc., marketers for the tooth whitening product, Klear Action Whitening System, has substantiated safety and quantified shade claims made in its direct response advertising and also recommended that the marketer modify other core claims concerning comparisons to dentist office products and its receipt of pre-market notification. Concerns about the truth and accuracy of the marketer’s claims came to the attention of ERSP from its ongoing monitoring program.

In the inquiry for the Klear Action Whitening System, ERSP requested that the marketer provide substantiation for: general performance claims (i.e., “in under 45 minutes…6 shades lighter.”); establishment claims (i.e., “Clinically proven, without any tooth sensitivity, to get teeth up to six shades whiter in under an hour.”); comparative market claims (i.e., “Dentist office results without going to the dentist…up to six shades lighter or more, with no sensitivity, in under an hour, at a fraction of the cost.”) and safety claims (i.e., “completely safe.”).

ERSP determined that Thane, provided a reasonable basis for its quantified, 5 shade improvement claim, and it was determined that an “up to 6 shade improvement” claim was appropriate.  Moreover, questions of product safety were adequately addressed by the voluntary modifications made by Thane to clarify zero tooth sensitivity, rather than zero sensitivity, the marketer’s acquisition of the 510k pre-market notification by the FDA, and the use of the accepted 11% concentration of hydrogen peroxide in the product.

However, ERSP determined that the number of product applications required to achieve the level of shade improvement claimed in the advertisement should be disclosed to consumers and that this clarification would also satisfy ERSP’s concern over the comparative speed claims communicated by the infomercial. While ERSP agreed with Thane that the Klear Action uses the “same type of professional light treatment” that is used in dental offices it was not persuaded that claims pertaining to the “same type of whitening agent” as professionally administered products would be understood as clearly.  Finally, ERSP marketer’s independent actions to modify the claims that its product had been “approved” by the FDA.

In response to ERSP’s decision, Thane International, Inc responded it is was “… pleased that ERSP concluded that a substantial number of the claims investigated by the organization, including the claim, “Clinically proven wit hout any tooth sensitivity, to get teeth up to six shades whiter in under an hour were adequately substantiated…” and while respectfully disagreeing with the standard employed by ERSP in interpreting claims and the conclusions of ERSP it nevertheless agreed to “…take ERSP’s recommendations into consideration and appropriately modify its advertising.”

 

Subscribe to the Ad Law Insights or Privacy Initiatives newsletters for an exclusive monthly analysis and insider perspectives on the latest trends and case decisions in advertising law and data privacy.

 

 

 

 

Latest Decisions

Decision

National Advertising Division Finds Realtor.com “#1 Site Real Estate Professionals Trust” Claim Supported

New York, NY – November 8, 2024 – In a challenge brought by competitor CoStar Group, the National Advertising Division determined that Move provided a reasonable basis for its claim that Realtor.com is the “#1 site real estate professionals trust.

Read the Decision Summary
Decision

National Advertising Division Recommends Verizon Discontinue or Modify Certain Claims for Satellite-Supported Texting Services

New York, NY – November 7, 2024 – In a Fast-Track SWIFT challenge brought by T-Mobile, the National Advertising Division recommended that Verizon either discontinue certain claims about satellite-supported texting services in remote locations or modify them to disclose the necessary conditions for Verizon customers...

Read the Decision Summary
Decision

Following National Advertising Division Challenge, PetIQ Voluntarily Discontinues Certain Claims for NextStar Flea & Tick Topical

New York, NY – November 6, 2024 – Following a National Advertising Division challenge, PetIQ discontinued certain claims for its NextStar Flea & Tick topical flea prevention and treatment product, which appeared on PetIQ’s website, social media, and third-party websites.

Read the Decision Summary
Decision

National Advertising Division Finds Certain Safety Claims for Drunk Elephant Skincare Products Supported; Recommends Modification of Influencer Posts

New York, NY – November 4, 2024 – The National Advertising Division determined certain Drunk Elephant social media claims regarding skincare products being “safe for kids and tweens to use” were supported, but determined that two TikTok video influencer disclosures for Drunk Elephant's B-Goldi...

Read the Decision Summary